cover image Without Sin: 2the Life and Death of the Oneida Community

Without Sin: 2the Life and Death of the Oneida Community

Spencer Klaw. Viking Books, $25 (352pp) ISBN 978-0-7139-9091-1

From 1848 to 1880 a unique experiment in cooperative living took place in Oneida, N.Y. This was a utopian socialistic society founded by John Humphrey Noyes, a follower of Christian Perfectionism, a belief in moral perfection and in separation from the world of sinners. Drawing on documents left by some of the original 200-plus members, Klaw ( The Great American Medicine Show ) provides an informative account of the commune. In his striving for the perfection of life without sin, Noyes imposed ``complex marriage'' at Oneida, a system that provided men and women with multiple sex partners and prohibited monogamy because ``it impeded the free flow of Christian love.'' Conception of children was forbidden unless Noyes approved of the genetic attributes of the prospective parents. Members pooled their labor and had cooperative ownership of the animal trap and silverware business that supported them. After Noyes fled to Canada in 1879 in fear of prosecution for unorthodox sex practices, residents gradually adopted more traditional social arrangements. (Sept.)