Publishers Weekly Mobile
Log In  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Subscribe to Publishers Weekly Magazine
Email
Learn RSS

ShelfTalker: A Children's Bookseller's Blog   



Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (49)


Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family

October 2, 2008

It's time again for me to post a question that originally appeared on the walls of the "graffiti stall" in our store's women's bathroom. (See my 6/18/08 post if you don't know the "graffiti stall" of which I speak!)

Poor, poor you! You're a literary orphan with no parents to call your own. What fictional family would you like to have adopt you?

After giving this one lots of thought I'm going to go with either the March family of Little Women or... the Mysterious Benedict Society, which certainly counts as a "family" if you ask me.

Now it's your turn.


Posted by Alison Morris on October 2, 2008 | Comments (49)


Email
Learn RSS


October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Rdr commented:

The Weasley's, of course...Although I do love the March family.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Jesseja commented:

I think i'd like to be a Weasley.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Gayle Carline commented:

I think it would be fun to be Tarzan and Jane's daughter.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Vexil commented:

I always wanted to live with the Melendys from Elizabeth Enright's books, or with the family in Edward Eager's Half Magic.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
EM commented:

Do I have to choose just one? Probably the Krupniks, then (though I'd also be happy with the Cassons, Penderwicks, Moodys, and whatever Clementine's last name is).




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Cassie commented:

I'd want Mr. Bennett for a father, although I really don't want the rest of the Bennett family... Maybe Ender's parents from Ender's Game. They're incredibly intelligent but let their kids go their own way--and then pull them back when they screw up.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Susan Brown commented:

The Penderwicks have definite appeal! For some reason this made me ponder the other side of the coin--what family would I never want to join as an adoptee. When I re-read Harriet the Spy as an adult, I was so struck by their dysfunctionality. I don't think I picked up on that when I read the book as a 6th grader.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
teacherninja commented:

The Lazardo Family (of Dinosaur Bob Fame). Those guys have style, a butler, AND a flippin DINOSAUR. And Trixie's parents seem pretty cool (Knuffle Bunny). Any adult fiction families or just children's books?




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
MM commented:

The Austins from Madeleine L'Engle's Meet the Austins. I'd like to live next door to the Penderwicks.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
reader4 commented:

Without a doubt...one of the Cullens.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
cbroadwe commented:

The Murry family from the Madeleine L'Engle books. Those kids always got in the most interesting adventures, and their parents were pretty cool. Plus, they lived next door to Calvin O'Keefe, one of my early crushes. I was totally envious of Meg, despite her insecurity issues.

Next, you should ask what fictional character we would marry if we could!




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Julianne Daggett commented:

I'd definitely have to go with the Weasleys.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Kat B commented:

I always thought it would be the coolest thing in the world to have Morticia Addams as a mum.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Heather Shrader commented:

I have always had a very loose definition of "family" and would like to include in this question a "family of friends" - With that in mind I would have to choose for my "family of friends" - The entire town of Green Gables.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
lgromalama commented:

It's a toss-up between the March family or the Peppers (5 Little Peppers Series by Margaret Sidney). What a fun question!




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
ShelfTalker commented:

Teacherninja, You are welcome to suggest families from fiction for ANY age group. Interesting to wonder, though, if there ARE as many appealing-sounding families in adult fiction... I can think of one I'd love to be part of, though: Jim's family from Jim the Boy and the recently published sequel The Blue Star by Tony Earley. In fact, Jim's family might even trump the ones I mentioned earlier.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
tericoyne commented:

I always wanted to be in Laura Ingalls Wilder's family and be in the Little House in the Big Woods.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
*h. commented:

i always wanted to be one of the moomins. (tove jansson: genius.) i would make a lovely snorkmaiden.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
suekush commented:

Hans and Rosa Hubermann from The Book Thief. Not really Rosa, but I'd put up with her for Hans.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Four Story Mistake commented:

Vexil- I guess I'd be your sister- I'm definitely in with the Melendys or in Half Magic. Maybe the Pratts (from the Facts and Fictions of Minna Pratt) or the Pyes (from Pinky Pye). Ooh! Too many! I'd also love the Ridgeways from Family Sabbatical.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Jo Beth Dempsey commented:

Love this question! I loved reading about the Moffats way back when and I would have loved Rufus as a brother (I have 3 younger sisters, no brothers). However, I also identified with the Marches, the Melendys, the Austins, the Murrays, and now the Penderwicks.




October 2, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
ZB commented:

I would love to be a Weasely, I have the red hair so I'll fit right in! To that extent, I suppose I could pose as an Anne as well... choices, choices!




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
ELIZABETH BLUEMLE commented:

I might have to go with the Casson family!




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Noa Wheeler commented:

Murry family, hands down (you could tesser for family vacations!), though the Austins come a close second (even though they're quite religious and I'm not--I feel that they'd tolerate me). Maybe that just means I'd choose Madeleine L'Engle?




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Erlene commented:

I never read a family I liked better than my own parents although I always wanted to go and live with Pippi Longstocking! I just wanted to be in charge!




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Maheneen commented:

I want to be adopted by Derk and Mara from the Dark Lord of Derkholm.




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Trixie commented:

I would have a lot of fun de-gnoming the garden at the Weasleys. I have to go with the Weasleys. But I would add Pippi Longstocking as one of my sisters. Can you imagine Pippi with MAGIC? We'd have a BLAST.




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
CuriousCity commented:

The Cassons! The Hilary McKay novels are just about the funniest books I have ever read--they make me snort. I never read them because SAFFY'S ANGEL had that dreadful cover that made me think it was one of those "heartfelt" books.

Of course, I would have to be named after a paint color. I choose...Alizarin, Alice for short.




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
J.Kasten commented:

When I was little I wanted to be one of the Pevensey's, because I wanted to be in Narnia and see Aslan, but today I immediately thought of the Melendy's. Now I'm thinking "




October 3, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
J.Kasten commented:

Sorry, it cut me off. I was thinking, "definitely, the Blackett sisters. Swallows and Amazons forever!"




October 4, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Rdr1 commented:

I wouldn't mind being a Belden- I always had a fictional crush on Jim. And I wouldn't mind marrying Edward and becoming a Cullen!!




October 5, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Andrea Beaty commented:

I asked my daughter which literary family she'd like to join and she said the Baudelaires. I'm not sure how to take that.




October 6, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Dani commented:

I'd like to go live with Dracula and see what the night is really like.




October 6, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Karin commented:

I would enjoy living with Nancy Drew and her cool, calm and collected father. No mater what kind of jam she got herself into, he never got as mad as most parents would.




October 6, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Nancy commented:

Love so many of the families mentioned. I loved the extended family in the All of a Kind Family books. I also loved Eloise's life with her push-over Nanny and the tutor she managed to turn into a puddle every time. Of course growing up with totally absent and neglectful parents can't have been good in the long run! But it's true that there is really something to many books where the parents just don't figure in. The Narnia books...and others mentioned.




October 7, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Katherine commented:

hhm could I be Harriet, marrying into Peter Wimsley's family?




October 7, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Jessica commented:

I'd want to be a member of the Ray family from the Betsy-Tacy series. To have Mr. Ray and Mrs Ray for parents would be bliss. You'd might have to keep Julia out of my face, though.




October 7, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Laura commented:

Definitely the Rays, the Melendys, or the All-of-a-kind Family (especially since I'm Jewish). Or the Grandparents from "The Golden Name Day" by Jennie Lindquist.




October 15, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Abigail commented:

Okay, it took me forever before I got a chance to read and think about this, but I've ALWAYS wanted to be one of the "All-of-a-Kind Family" (only kid I know who wanted to live in a tenement) or sisters with Sarah Crewe (also the only kid I know who wanted to be a scullery maid). The Cuthberts/Blythes, depending on my mood and which book in the series is appealing to me, were very close seconds.




October 16, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Christine commented:

Not exactly a family, but I would love to live in Miss Read's "Fairacre".




October 16, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Penny Jo commented:

Murrys, Austins, and Weasleys are all good. But I'd also like to be a kid of Mr. and Mrs. Popper and slide down the frozen stairs on my stomach with those penguins!




October 17, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Emily Noon commented:

I'd say the Melendys (I just reread "The Four-Story Mistake," and it's still wonderful). For a real-life family, I always wanted to be a Bronte, live on the moors, and play all those wonderful writing games with my sibs . . . leaving out all the hard parts of their lives, of course.




October 17, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Emily Noon commented:

I'd say the Melendys (I just reread "The Four-Story Mistake," and it's still wonderful). For a real-life family, I always wanted to be a Bronte, live on the moors, and play all those wonderful writing games with my sibs . . . leaving out all the hard parts of their lives, of course.




October 17, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Lauren M commented:

An Alden from the Boxcar Children!




October 17, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Clara commented:

The Caraway family from Stargirl and Love, Stargirl by Jerry Spinelli.




October 17, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Brooke commented:

I concur with the person who wanted to live with the family from <i>Dark Lord of Derkholm</i> -- when I read the question, I immediately thought about living with Christopher Chant's family!




October 21, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
bookin commented:

As a young girl I loved the Trixie Belden series, so I would either want to part of Trixie's family or one of the Wheelers.






November 17, 2008
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
JJ commented:

I'll second the vote for the Ray Family (Betsy-Tacy).




September 2, 2009
In response to: Wall Scrawl: Choose Your Fictional Family
Adriana commented:

I would create my own fictional family and be adopted by them, or a family from Lord of the Rings would be cool.





POST A COMMENT
Display Name or Registered Users Login Here.
Please restrict submissions to less than 7,000 characters (including any HTML formatting).

Change Image
Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above.
Note the letters are NOT case sensitive.

Advertisement

Advertisements



SUBSCRIBE to PW


Virtual Edition



©2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites