Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
The Book Maven   


Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (5)


Eyes on the Prizes
April 13, 2007

As far as I'm concerned, there can never be too many book prizes.

Or not?

Even as I wrote that first statement and linked to John Fraser's excellent Globe and Mail article about the Man Booker International Prize (not to be confused with the Man Booker Prize itself), I found myself wondering if that gut reaction is a sane one.

Fraser writes:

"'Another damn book prize?"

More than a few skeptics snarled the question when it was learned that something called "the Man Booker International Prize" was somehow going to be announced at Massey College in Toronto in April, 2007.

Between the Giller Prize and the Governor-General's Literary Awards, between the Orange and the Pulitzer and the Prix Goncourt and, well . . . dammit, the annual Booker Prize for Fiction and the bloody Nobel Prize for Literature itself: enough!

Well, no. Not enough, in fact. There's never enough to be done for the beleaguered world of books. If anything will get a worthy offering off a seller's shelves and into the hands of a willing reader, even by curiosity aroused through the latest "damn book prize," then all well and good, or even better!"

I feel his pain. The world of books, we all know, is beleaguered, for many many many reasons. We've all heard them.

But does any attention at all equal worthwhile attention? Can contests and prizes help, or do they attract the attention of book people only?

I don't have an answer. I am reminded, however, of the dictum "There's no such thing as bad publicity."

What do you think? Should there be as many contest, prizes, and winning books as possible? Or not?


Posted by Bethanne Patrick on April 13, 2007 | Comments (5)


April 13, 2007
In response to: Eyes on the Prizes
gondaba commented:

Book prizes are a great method for exposure. I would like to see more book prizes awarded to unknown and underrated books.




April 13, 2007
In response to: Eyes on the Prizes
Brian Hadd commented:

Proust, Tolstoy and Joyce are all the endorsement any prize earns. The Nobel record of these greats can only hearten those who may not be up to competing, exactly.




April 13, 2007
In response to: Eyes on the Prizes
bookishblondish commented:

Too many awards make all the awards a little less meaningful; although, I do not think we have reached that level yet. Wouldn't it be nice to see literary stars being treated to a SWAGbag full of treats a la the Oscars... now there's a veue with too many awards ceremonies




April 13, 2007
In response to: Eyes on the Prizes
BigRich commented:

Prizes, like the art they reward are terribly subjective. Setting aside politics, who are the judges to judge and who adjudged them worthy of dispensing criticism. Unlike, say baseball which offers statistical empiricism from which to rank players (and even that's far from perfect in many categories) art is different --- and thank heavens it is so. Reminds me of the controversy surrounding Harold Bloom when he pitched a canon of literature for all collegians --- or the cultural literacy movement dashed on the shores of PC'ism. I agree that the publicity sword can strike deep across the consciousness bringing conscious readers to art, but is the game worth the candle.




April 16, 2007
In response to: Eyes on the Prizes
Julie commented:

Recognition is essential to creative people. In this world prizes are given for endless endeavors including stuffing as much of a certain food as possible in one's face to earn the record of the one who can eat the most in a given period time!! Writers provide society with so much and many deserve a prize be it a major one or a smaller acknowledment of their efforts.





POST A COMMENT
Display Name or Registered Users Login Here.
Please restrict submissions to less than 7,000 characters (including any HTML formatting).

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above:


Advertisement

Advertisements



VIRTUAL EDITION


Virtual Edition



©2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites