Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
The Book Maven   


Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (6)


Recommended Reading: "Classics for Pleasure"
November 14, 2007

There are a few people out there who read more than I do and no, I'm not talking about Harriet Klausner... I'm talking about people like Michael Dirda, the Pulitzer-Prize winning critic and author of the new book Classics for Pleasure

                                                         Cover Image

Reading Dirda's essay collection resembles sitting down in a comfy bar with an old friend and nattering on about books with no particular agenda or time limit. Like me, he's enthusiastic about his favorite books; unlike me, he's able to point you to specific passages in scores of books that make them relevant. 

I could mention any number of the works and authors that Dirda includes (Abolqasem Ferdowsi and Agatha Christie!), which better this week than Beowulf, since the movie, including Angelina Jolie as Grendel's dam, is opening? Dirda acknowledges the great poem's flaws: "...the last third of Beowulf can feel slightly thin, a bit of a let-down" and "its Old English is notoriously difficult even for graduate students in medieveal studies" (tell me about it... ), but he also reminds us that "Tolkien...stresses that the poem's somber power resides in the very compactness of its Anglo-Saxon diction... How else but in such bleakly beautiful poetry should we sing of warriors and heroes?"

See, Dirda really loves books -- it would never even occur to him that Jolie might figure in singing of warriors and heroes.

Posted by Bethanne Patrick on November 14, 2007 | Comments (6)


November 15, 2007
In response to: Recommended Reading: "Classics for Pleasure"
Amy Wachspress commented:

How the heck they got Angelina Jolie into Beowulf is beyond me. I struggled through it in Old English in graduate school and was the laughingstock of my class because I am so hopeless with foreign languages that I could make no sense out of it. There must be some academic reason to read this book but I can't think what. The only reason to watch a movie about it would be if they figured out a way to get someone like Angelina Jolie into it in skimpy medieval garb. I hope she's not covered in mud throughout the film. As Monty Python once said, you can tell the peasants from royalty because they are the ones covered in sh$%&t (have to watch my language or they won't accept my posting). You can find me at wozabooks.




November 15, 2007
In response to: Recommended Reading: "Classics for Pleasure"
Christine commented:

Umm...I know it's been three hundred years since I was in college, but wasn't Grendel's mother supposed to be hideously ugly? I mean, one reason why I divorced my ex was because he named his new dog "Grendel", which made me Grendel's mother. Anyway - "Classics for Pleasure" sounds like the way I envisioned college, a pre-Harry Potter vision of Hogwarts for the post-adolescent that did not include panty raids.




November 15, 2007
In response to: Recommended Reading: "Classics for Pleasure"
NANCY YANES HOFFMAN commented:

Who is the publisher of Dirda's book and what is the pub date?




November 15, 2007
In response to: Recommended Reading: "Classics for Pleasure"
Charles commented:

Sounds like a fascinating read. In the last year I read a couple "classics for pleasure": Twain's "Pudd'nhead Wilson" & Thackeray's masterpiece "Vanity Fair". Both fabulous reads, with the edge going to VF. I read an edition with Thackeray's own illustrations, which add to the pleasure. And I heard recently that Beowulf will be one of the Oscar nominees in the Animated Films category! ?? And Angelina Jolie of course used a body double for the nude scenes. So is it still a cartoon?




November 16, 2007
In response to: Recommended Reading: "Classics for Pleasure"
Bethanne commented:

Nancy Yanes Hoffman, Dirda's book is out now from Harcourt (further book info available at the link or by clicking on the book jacket image). Charles, "Vanity Fair" is such a gorgeous read; I'm going to seek out an edition with Thackeray's illustrations for the next time I pick it up. Christine, I am still laughing at your pre-Harry Potter vision of Hogwarts... I spent a summer session at an Oxford college years ago and am still miffed that I got a 1960s-era room instead of one surrounded by gargoyles and such. Amy, I promise you that in Old English "Beowulf" has a stately elegaic cadence. However, since those qualities don't translate easily into modern English, I don't know if they will translate to the screen, or not.




November 17, 2007
In response to: Recommended Reading: "Classics for Pleasure"
Kevin A. Lewis commented:

A certain liberty with Beowulf is unavoidable, since it wasn't meant to read iin novel form, rather, it was meant to be chanted while drunk out of your mind around a meadhall fire...Tough ambience to recreate these days.





POST A COMMENT
Display Name or Registered Users Login Here.
Please restrict submissions to less than 7,000 characters (including any HTML formatting).

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above:


Advertisement

Advertisements



VIRTUAL EDITION


Virtual Edition



©2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites