Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
The Book Maven   


Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (8)


What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
April 18, 2007

Yesterday, my friend and colleague Carol Fitzgerald sent me this blog entry she wrote about how Jodi Picoult's Nineteen Minutes had influenced her perspective on the recent Virginia Tech tragedy. It's a beautiful example of what books can do, and do best -- widen our own perspectives on the world.

My heart goes out to the victims, to everyone in Blacksburg, and to all of the affected friends and family around the country.

I found myself thinking again about Carol's post and how books influence us all when I saw a line from Isak Dinesen on The Writer's Almanac: "All sorrows can be borne, if you put them into a story."

I pray that someday someone is able to put the huge weight of this massacre's sorrows into a story, and that it will help many people to bear it. Cho Seung-Hui was an English major, and he put many of his disturbed thoughts into poetry and plays. His professors, like English Department Chair Lucinda Roy, saw that his own stories were full of sorrows that could not be explained by words -- they recommended counselling, and it is tragic, too, that Cho did not receive any.

Cho, disturbed as he was, tried to use the power of words -- and failed. Which is why I wonder less about the impact of gun control on this situation than I wonder about the impact of intervention. I'm not saying that gun control isn't relevant -- just that my thoughts are focused on how difficult it is for us to get help to those suffering from mental illness.

In the meantime, I hope that those in mourning don't give up on poetry, plays, and novels as comfort and as ways through to peace.


Posted by Bethanne Patrick on April 18, 2007 | Comments (8)


April 18, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
gondaba commented:

hmm.. nothing.. and nothing?




April 18, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
Bethanne commented:

Yikes! Investigating...




April 18, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
Kevin A. lewis commented:

You're quite right that this kid was red-flagged as a danger to himself and others some time ago and nobody bothered to "intervene" or sweep his room for stockpiled artillery, but do we really need another 3-hankie moanfest about grief and sorrow?! That being said, Oprah will probably love it, so go make your fortune...




April 18, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
Brian Hadd commented:

Names and faces are human and people who see people for people use language for whatever. This would be the first foreign comment worth making.




April 19, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
Bethanne commented:

Kevin, it will be interesting to see if someone manages to write a novel about this incident that is NOT a moanfest. That's the one I'd want to read.




April 19, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
bookishblondish commented:

tragedy is the basis for so much great writing- fiction and nonfiction. Let's just hope that we see books come out of this that heal, and not reopen. Not sure how long it will be before someone tries to make a buck off this travesty.




April 21, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
Kevin A. Lewis commented:

As far as trying to make a buck off this travesty, I'm sure somebody's already power-lunching the idea as we speak-the only reason I don't do it is because those kind of restaurants are way over my budget, and if the idea went through, I'd have to find a new way to shave in the morning that didn't involve looking at myself in the mirror....




April 21, 2007
In response to: What Books Can Do -- And What They Can't
Joanie commented:

Jody Picoult stopped writing quality fiction years ago when she decided to concentrate on "hot" topics and write a book a year. Her research is sloppy at best, some scenes in her books are ludicrous, and her female characters exist in isolation, with no friends or companions. Totally unrealistic, but that is how she advances her plots.





POST A COMMENT
Display Name or Registered Users Login Here.
Please restrict submissions to less than 7,000 characters (including any HTML formatting).

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above:


Advertisement

Advertisements



VIRTUAL EDITION


Virtual Edition



©2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites