Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Beyond Her Book   


Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (18)


Time for a Rant
April 3, 2007

Time for a rant.  I just finished a book that was so embarrassingly full of spelling, grammar and story errors, that I couldn't concentrate on the plot.  The worst was 5 mistakes in ten pages.  If I would have had my red pen handy, it would have run out of ink.

Now, I don't know about you, but I feel this is a sad commentary on the publishing industry.  This book was by a bestselling author and it reflects not only badly on her, but on the editor and publisher.  Is anyone reading these things before they're printed?  Or is it just run past spellcheck??

They're, there and their all mean different things (this is where a dictionary might come in handy).  If the character's name is Jack for the first 150 pages, don't change it to Jake for a sentence (who the heck is Jake anyway?).  It is awkward when Sean says, "What is Sean doing now?" (unless he usually talks about himself in the third person).   When writing a historical romance, refrain from having the characters call each other "Hey, Dude" (okay, I haven't seen that yet, but I'm sure it's just a matter of time).

Whew...I feel better now.  I'll just open this next book where the prologue begins "April 31, 1999."  Wait a minute, aren't there 30 days in April?

Bottom Line:  If there are any errors in this blog, it's not my fault.

 


Posted by Barbara Vey on April 3, 2007 | Comments (18)


April 3, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
joysannoh commented:

This is my favorite peeve also! Me and him (whoever)go nuts and distracted over typos, grammatical and vocabulary errors. Not that I'm prefect...spellcheck might do a better job than me. lol & thanks.




April 3, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Joan commented:

Couldn't agree more. Other people however, have been know to suggest that I'm just being 'hard to get on with' when I rant about this very subject.




April 3, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Katy commented:

Oh, I hate this!!!! I am so obsessive, that I can't just skip the error, either. I have to figure out what was really suppose to be there in its place. Which then makes me more mad because I lost my momentum.




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Gerald Zimmerman commented:

It makes me mad too. After paying a high price for a book, and then to find numerous spelling errors is just not acceptable. One mistake--maybe. More than two is unacceptable!




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Chris St. John commented:

The 4 comments I have read contain mistakes...so, this is a joke, right?




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Barbara Vey commented:

Sorry Chris, no joke. These comments are not from paid professionals, so mistakes are ok. When you pay good money for a book, the expectation is for it to be done well.




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Dolphinover commented:

I agree. When you pay good money for a book, the expection should be high.




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
lola library commented:

We're in agreement here. Nothing worse than correcting spelling and grammar. It takes away from the pleasure of reading.




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Rachel commented:

I can't agree more, I read a book we set in the early 1800's and the man asked the women if she would like to "go out". Now the reference was as in dating, maybe I'm wrong but didn't that phrase start in the 1990's?




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
motherof3 commented:

My mother always corrected my spelling and grammar, as I'm doing for my children. Isn't it a pride thing about ones work.




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
diva deb commented:

Grammar duh! what's dat.




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
LighthouseLady/Lynda commented:

I so agree with you about errors in books. I just don't understand it. I did alot of proof reading for manuals and I just can't go on till I mark the error in RED. I had one book that was so bad, I marked it up and sent it back to the author telling her to find a new editor/publisher.




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
RevDeb commented:

Boy I can't stand that either. I'm glad someone else brought this up! Thank you!




April 4, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Christy commented:

I suppose I've been fortunate in that the books I've read have had very few errors. Perhaps I've been so engrossed in the story that I somehow miss them, especially if the words are "flowing" for me. But 5 errors in 10 pages? Yes, that would have annoyed me, too.




April 5, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Rika commented:

Barb, That's bad! I also hate it when the characters names change! There was one book that had a dead character asking a question. LOL... Someone didn't do their job with this book. I bet the author is highly embarrassed at all the mistakes. It's a shame. I know that at least 5 or 6 people check for spelling and grammar errors before a book goes out. So why did this one have so many mistakes? Definitely not pleasant reading.




April 9, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
coco commented:

I see this also in scholarly books and usually circle it. It makes me wonder what the editor is paid to do. Maybe they should skip the editing process and just send a first draft to readers for comments and corrections. We are on the alert!




April 11, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
Anne Heely commented:

I am so glad not to be alone in this subject. I, too, am often called "picky" when pointing out errors. I even wrote to an author once who kept using the phrase "He wiped the back of his mouth with his hand" That would be a real feat. Thanks for starting your rant!




April 18, 2007
In response to: Time for a Rant
CHRISTINE commented:

I once contacted an author because I enjoyed his book very much but it had continuity errors that drove me nuts. His reply was that what had mistakenly been published was an uncorrected proof. Although it seems that the budget for line editors and proofreaders is going the way of the dodo, at at least some publishing companies.





POST A COMMENT
Display Name or Registered Users Login Here.
Please restrict submissions to less than 7,000 characters (including any HTML formatting).

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above:


Advertisement

Advertisements



VIRTUAL EDITION


Virtual Edition



©2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites