The Tale of the Firebird ) w"/>
 

SIMEON'S GIFT

Julie Andrews Edwards, Author, Emma Walton Hamilton, Author, Gennady Spirin, Illustrator
Julie Andrews Edwards, Author, Emma Walton Hamilton, Author, Gennady Spirin, Illustrator , illus. by Gennady Spirin. HarperCollins/Julie Andrews Collection $16.99 (40p) ISBN 978-0-06-008914-6
Reviewed on: 10/27/2003
Release date: 09/01/2003
Hardcover - 30 pages - 978-0-06-008915-3
Paperback - 40 pages - 978-0-06-008916-0
Show other formats
FORMATS

While celebrity power and the packaged CD of the famed entertainer reading the text may spur sales for this book, it is Spirin's (The Tale of the Firebird ) work that merits the kudos. Paying homage to the Italian Renaissance, his watercolors are simply exquisite, as is the book design. Set like jewels on a thin necklace of gold lines, oval details of larger paintings border the text. Other pages feature lush landscapes with the text centered on a white moon of space, with the reverse layout (circular image on white ground) opposite on the right. However, the story is fairly pedestrian. Simeon, a penniless lute-player, leaves his noble ladylove because he wants "to free the music he was certain lay deep in his soul." When he returns, he brings her a quasi-magical fish, bird and fawn, as well as a song he has composed himself. Unfortunately, the mother-daughter team (the Dumpy the Dump Truck series) never develops a music of its own. The text is a pastiche of abstractions about a character with a "heavy heart," despondent because he is so "overwhelmed and unable to make sense of the discord in his head." As a result, Simeon often seems more like a sighing medieval slacker in search of focus than a hero, and makes the ending moral—"that a true and brave heart can find a way, if it will only trust in all the wonders under God's canopy"—seem hollow. Ages 5-9. (Oct.)

The Best Books, Emailed Every Week
Tip Sheet!
MORE BOOKS YOU'D LIKE
X