cover image Scar Island

Scar Island

Dan Gemeinhart. Scholastic Press, $16.99 (256p) ISBN 978-1-338-05384-5

The opening chapters of Gemeinhart’s (Some Kind of Courage) fast-paced novel, set in a boys’ reformatory school on a remote island, immediately bring to mind the sadistic adults and helpless boys of Louis Sachar’s Holes, but the situation soon changes to a Lord of the Flies scenario. There are 16 “troubled boys” at Slabhenge, a “hulking, jagged building of gray stone” crumbling into the sea, sent there for a variety of crimes, but 12-year-old Jonathan Grisby believes himself to be the worst; exactly what he has done comes out in bits and pieces until the complete truth is revealed in the book’s suspenseful climax. The creepy setting is almost over-the-top, complete with an ancient librarian with a giant pet rat, who gives Jonathan—appropriately enough—a copy of Robinson Crusoe to read to the others. While only a few of the boys are fleshed out enough to be fully dimensional, the group dynamics of leadership and peer pressure are well depicted and will inspire thoughtful discussion. Ages 8–12. Agent: Pam Howell, D4EO Literary. (Jan.)