Karen Haber, Editor, John Owen, Illustrator, John Howe, Illustrator , illus. by John Howe. St. Martin's $24.95 (288p) ISBN 978-0-312-27536-5

An unapologetic tie-in with the release of the first highly anticipated Lord of the Rings film, this anthology presents appreciative essays in honor of the master of Middle-earth from such major fantasy and SF authors as Harry Turtledove, Raymond Feist, Terry Pratchett, George R.R. Martin and the late Poul Anderson. All thank Tolkien, some sardonically, for making the fantasy genre so popular. Ursula K. Le Guin discusses obvious and concealed poetry in the trilogy, while Douglas A. Anderson treats Tolkien's critics, admitting that the posthumously published writings, edited by the author's son, Christopher, are "not always easy to read," a view seconded by several other contributors. Less successful as a scholarly exercise is Orson Scott Card's "How Tolkien Means," which focuses on allegory, a mode Tolkien rejected. Most contributors celebrate the beauty of the writing in the major books, although Michael Swanwick finds them "sad with wisdom" in his essay, "A Changling Returns." Swanwick takes the lead in pointing out the importance of the humble hobbit Sam Gamgee as a character. In a dialogue between illustrators and brothers Tim and Greg Hildebrandt, Tim admits that "Tolkien was never a big supporter of illustration to accompany works of fantasy." Alas, Howe's vague and unimaginative pencil sketches only serve to support Tolkien's case. Editor Haber offers an adoring but welcome antidote to the more pompous exegeses of the "author of the century." (Nov. 23)

FYI:For more on hobbit fever, see "Movie Hype Is No Fantasy" and "Lord of the Rings Redux" (PW, Sept. 10).

Reviewed on: 10/22/2001
Release date: 11/01/2001
Paperback - 256 pages - 978-0-7434-6874-9
Paperback - 256 pages - 978-0-312-30290-0
Open Ebook - 288 pages - 978-1-4299-7473-8
Show other formats
The Best Books, Emailed Every Week
Tip Sheet!