Heartsblood, C

David Petersen, Author, Ted Williams, Foreword by Island Press $25 (288p) ISBN 978-1-55963-761-9
Petersen brings an uncommonly broad perspective to this highly personal, passionate and deeply persuasive argument for responsible hunting. He reminds us that humans have been predominantly hunters for 99% of our species' history; by comparison agriculture occupies merely a brief moment in the human timeline and the era of shrink-wrapped supermarket meat even less. Biologically, we were built to hunt, he contends, a reality carved into the human genome as deeply as wildness imprints the genetic makeup of prey. Denying our genetic predisposition makes us less than fully human, he argues, which will undoubtedly strike many as radical. But Petersen is not a polemicist bent on pushing every citizen into hunting. In fact, he calls himself a ""fence-straddler,"" an advocate of animal welfare (which he differentiates from animal rights) who has been criticized by antihunters as ""rabidly prohunting"" and knocked by hunters' rights advocates as ""an anti in hunter's camouflage."" Much of Petersen's argument (his delineation of the three different types of hunters, his criticism of holier-than-thou vegetarianism, his disdain of trophy hunting) treads a well-worn path, but this ambivalence lends his conclusions greater credibility. More unique and provocative is his contention that humans, far from evolving beyond the need to kill our own food, instead risk devolving when we avoid facing firsthand the deaths that sustain our survival. Though he goes overboard in strumming the mystical chord and seems at times too fond of inflated language, Petersen's ambitious analysis of this contentious issue is impressively well reasoned. (Sept.)
Reviewed on: 07/31/2000
Release date: 08/01/2000
The Best Books, Emailed Every Week
Tip Sheet!