When Heroes Fall: Healing from the Aftermath of Sin

Fields (When Faith Disappoints), CEO of the Jude 3 Project, an apologetics organization, outlines in this flimsy guide how to recover from betrayal at the hands of a pastor, parent, or other person one looks up to. She argues that putting such “heroes” on a pedestal obscures their weaknesses, suggesting that readers embrace a more “nuanced” view that acknowledges their flaws along with the ways God has used them to “do good in your life.” Readers are advised to grapple with the pain of betrayal through therapy, journaling, and community support; work to extend forgiveness to the person in question; and pray for their redemption or, when appropriate, “check in regularly as we gently and humbly point them back to God.” Believers are also reminded to strengthen their faith and look to Jesus for wisdom rather than placing too much stock in inherently fallible human leaders. Unfortunately, much of the author’s argument feels familiar, and she bolsters it with odd examples (ranging from Sean “Diddy” Combs to King David) and questionable suggested practices like fasting to help the fallen hero work toward redemption. Hurt believers would be better served elsewhere. (June)