Erskine ( Lady of Hay ) undertakes an ambitious dual plot with middling success in this novel of romance and the supernatural. Her tale interlaces the lives of two women: Isobel of Fife, an actual 13th-century heroine of Scotland's bloody wars to win freedom from the English monarchs; and Clare Royland, a fictional modern-day descendant destined to undergo a contemporary version of Isobel's suffering in order to free her ancestor's spirit from bondage to their ancestral home, Duncairn. Chronicling her rebellion against her husband and England, Isobel's fictionalized biography is absorbing and richly textured, standing on its own as a drama of love and patriotism with a bittersweet ending. Clare's story, a contemporary romantic thriller about domestic brutality and the machinations of greedy developers and shady investment brokers, simply cannot match the historical saga's emotional impact. The book's overall structure founders, ironically due to Erskine's consummate skill in bringing the past to life: Isobel's adventures are characterized by taut suspense, while Clare's are mere melodrama. Doubleday Book Club featured alternate; Literary Guild alternate. (Nov.)
Reviewed on: 01/01/1989 Release date: 01/01/1989 Genre:
During the Covid-19 crisis, Publishers Weekly is providing free digital access to our magazine, archive, and website. To receive the access to the latest issue delivered to your inbox free each week, enter your email below.