In last week’s issue, we published a map of every current and planned Amazon Books physical bookstore (visit publishersweekly.com/amazonbooksmap for an interactive version). Unsurprisingly, the story sparked plenty of debate online about how Amazon’s expansion of its bricks-and-mortar presence helps or hurts the book biz and book lovers. Two readers got into a compelling debate:
“I’m reading about Amazon opening stores at a more rapid clip in neighborhoods and communities that have probably been starved for (any) bookstore for several years.” —John Bouldry
“These are NOT neighborhoods starving for bookstores, indie or otherwise. Quite the opposite: Amazon is shouldering its way into communities where indies have long been successful and supported. Why would Amazon go into a community where the bookstores have already shuttered (most often due to being unable to compete with Amazon’s predatory practices)? These B&M stores are intended to chase out the few remaining survivors who have thrived, DESPITE Amazon.” —Sarah Kimmell
“When Borders closed, and a few BNs afterward, Northside of Chicago became a Book Desert. There is no large-footprint general bookstore on the northside of Chicago.... I am curious to see how the Amazon merchandise plan by ranking benefits smaller or independent publishers that are either ignored by large chain or independent, or don’t get the benefit of strong handselling sales representation” —J.B.
“Amazon doesn’t do them any favors by a LONG shot.... Amazon stores aren’t ‘large-footprint general bookstores’ in the least. They are boutiques; Chicago’s is 6,000 sq. ft., much of which is dedicated to Amazon’s electronics offerings, and far less than 4000 titles. For comparison, B&N averages more than 20,000 sqft per store. So you can see EXACTLY what market Amazon is chasing after, and who they are intending to shut down next.” —S.K.
What do you think? Is Amazon’s expansion predatory or good news?
From the Newsletters
Hannah Tinti talks with her editor, Noah Eaker, about the editing process for her new novel, The Twelve Lives of Samuel Hawley.
A heartening, come-full-circle publishing story that spans a quarter century, starring Caitlyn Dlouhy and William Joyce.
Tips for getting self-published e-books into libraries.
Librarians: Want a sneak peek at each week’s starred reviews? Sign up for PW
Preview for Librarians and have highlights of the coming issue’s stars delivered to your inbox every Friday afternoon.
The most-read review on publishersweekly.com last week was The Ministry of Utmost Happiness by Arundhati Roy.
PW senior writer Andrew Albanese breaks down a controversial new bill that would politicize the Copyright Office and empower Donald Trump to pick the next register of copyrights.
An interview with Michelle Ollie and James Sturm, cofounders of the Center for Cartoon Studies, an acclaimed program for educating cartoonists.
Marcus Pfister talks about the 25th anniversary of his shimmery picture book star, Rainbow Fish, and about the latest entry in the series, You Can’t Win Them All, Rainbow Fish.
An ode to Enchanted Lion Books.
Alyssa Cole discusses her new book, An Extraordinary Union. And PW editorial director Jim Milliot explains how major publishers fared in 2016.